Home Food Allergies You be the Choose: Ought to Mother Press Expenses In opposition to...

You be the Choose: Ought to Mother Press Expenses In opposition to Sister for Purposely Exposing Son to Allergen?


Suppose you will have issues with household taking your youngster’s meals allergy critically? Right here’s a state of affairs that has one sister contemplating urgent costs towards the opposite for purposely endangering her son — and as we do with our “You be the Choose“ installments — we ask you to determine and hold forth.

A mother posting on reddit tells her story about dropping off her six-year-old son with an egg allergy at her sister’s home for a party.

What occurs subsequent is detailed within the put up entitled “AITA for taking my son residence when my sister gave him one thing he was allergic to?“ by person u/Vacation-Cattle-9666.

We’ve referred to the “AITA” subreddit (i.e. group) earlier than the place this story is posted. AITA is brief for “Am I the A-Gap” and it supplies a medium the place folks query their very own habits and readers vote.

Right here is the mother’s story:

I (32F) have a son (6M) who has allergic reactions. One in every of these allergic reactions is meals based mostly so I’m very cautious when getting ready his meals. His allergic reactions are reasonable so I don’t want an EpiPen however I nonetheless carry one simply to make sure. (The explanation I’m mentioning this may come up quickly)

My sister (38F) has three children of her personal who have been blessed with no allergic reactions to allow them to eat no matter they like. Her oldest (13M) had a party not way back however I had a piece associated appointment so I dropped my son off so he might attend. My sister is effectively conscious of his allergic reactions and I requested if she can be serving meals that was okay for him to eat. She assured me all was effectively however I now realize it wasn’t.

After I returned to choose him up he was coated in a rash and crying. I instantly acknowledged it as his allergy appearing up and referred to as my sister to the facet.

I requested if his meals had been cross contaminated however she straight out informed me she instantly gave him what he was allergic to. I almost flipped out and needed to go outdoors to settle down.

She defended her actions by saying I used to be ‘babying’ him and that he wanted to study to develop out of his allergy. She continued by saying she gave her boys every part in order that’s why they have been stronger and more healthy than my son.

I admit I screamed at her after that and mentioned some issues I’m not happy with however she angrily informed me that it was her son’s birthday and it wasn’t proper that my son was getting ‘particular’ meals from everybody else. I identified that his allergic reactions are nothing for him to really feel particular about and she or he countered by saying that if I’m so bothered by his itching I ought to give him the EpiPen so it might cease.

I instantly left in my automotive and after I regarded again and noticed that my son had lower himself throughout from scratching I cried. She referred to as me in the midst of the evening and angrily demanded that I apologize to her and her son for ruining his celebration however I hung up. AITA?

The mother adopted up with this replace:


I’m posting the replace right here since mods eliminated the final one.

From studying all of the feedback I made a decision to press costs towards my sister. Additionally I didn’t embrace this within the put up however my son has an egg allergy so I felt at fault for taking him to a celebration with pastries however I obtained a number of encouraging phrases so I do know I’m not at fault. Thanks to all of the Redditors that made me understand that I needed to get one thing performed as a result of if I’d performed one thing like this to one in every of her boys she would retaliate instantly. I don’t wish to go into full particulars however the cause I didn’t report what she did was as a result of she is in a custody battle together with her husband for her children and I didn’t need this to be another excuse towards her. Nevertheless I can’t ignore it any longer and though I don’t need her to lose her children I’ve to guard mine. She did this to herself and fortuitously my son appears high quality proper now however I’ll take him by the pediatrician later if I see any adjustments.

To this point, the put up has garnered some 7,200+ “upvotes”, which means the readers discover the subject fascinating no matter whose facet they take, and over 1,000 feedback have been left by readers with their suggestions.

Now we flip to you, our readers — lots of whom have been confronted with relations who “simply don’t get it” — and ask you to be the decide. Is the poster justified in urgent costs towards her sister, or is she overreacting? How would you will have dealt with the state of affairs? And what recommendation would you give the mother or sister?

Tell us within the feedback part beneath.